Friday, July 4, 2014

"When We Were Young and Unafraid" (through August 10, 2014) at the Manhattan Theater Club


When We Were Young and Unafraid
Cherry Jones (photo: Joan Marcus)


Having had the pleasure of seeing and enjoying two of Sarah Treem's plays ("A Feminine Ending," at Playwrights Horizons and "The How and the Why" at the McCarter Theater), I went to her third play with high expectations, many of which were met in the excellent production afforded it by the Manhattan Theater Club.  A major plus was the casting of Cherry Jones, who is following up her stunning performance last season in "The Glass Menagerie" in a role that once again shows her off as an actor that you must see no matter what she is in.

In this play, she is superb as the dedicated, no nonsense owner/manager of a Bed & Breakfast off the coast of Seattle. As an independent but socially committed spirit, she quietly and courageously uses her skills to maintain a safe house for abused/ brutalized women.  The play is set in 1972 at the time when women were making waves and taking a particularly robust stand on feminist issues.

Outspoken and an activist in her own way Agnes (Jones) is former nurse who lost her license for performing an abortion. She has not lost her skill or her compassion for those who find their way to her, but who, nevertheless, have to comply with her strict rules and regulations in order not to upset the regular guests. Her daily life is assertively free of activism, but rather one of commitment to the raising of her teenage daughter Penny (Morgan Saylor), and keeping her as best as she can from the issues that confront those whom she shelters.

The engrossing play centers about the relationship that develops between the sexually naive but nevertheless typically rebellious Penny and the battered married runaway Mary Anne (Zoe Kazan) who attempts to show Penny how to get a man's attention. A sound and fury-propelled Lesbian African-American activist Hannah (Cherise Boothe) finds her way into the mix to bring a little tumult to Agnes's life, as does an ingratiating Paul (Patch Darragh), a thirty-something divorced song-writer from San Francisco with an eye for MaryAnne.

Although we get the feeling that Treem's intention is to stuff as much feminist ideology into the plot as possible, each one of the short, swiftly paced and excellently acted scenes, under the expert direction of Pam MacKinnon (the most recent Broadway revival of "Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?"), moves logically and persuasively from one dramatic crisis to the next. While Treem's messaging is a bit problematic and is arguably made too paramount throughout, she is crafty enough of a playwright to make each of her characters interesting and credible.The play's expected explosive climax and its bittersweet resolve are played out dynamically within Scott Pask's fine single setting.

One little complaint: characters in the playbill should be listed in order of appearance, not in alphabetical order, to help the audience  (forget the critic) know who is/was and when.

"When We Were Young and Unafraid"
Manhattan Theater Club, at the City Center Stage 1. 131 W. 55th St.
For tickets ($89.00) go to ManhattanTheatreClub.com

No comments:

Post a Comment